I loveee eye pencils, I could just buy them all day and then end up using the same one everyday:
Roughly speaking, my favourite eye pencils are:
1. Urban Decay 24/7 (every damn shade)
2. Anna Sui Waterproof Eye Pencil (the Khaki is amazing)
3. Nars (Kyoto, Kaliste, Black Moon)
4. Shu Uemura Drawing Pencils (got all the shades, but doesn’t work well on the waterline)
5. Chanel Kohls (but not much of a shade selection).
I have sensitive eyes and watery ones at that so I need a pencil to be very soft and creamy, and most don’t come off easily on my waterline since it’s always a bit moist (why does moist sound like a rude word?!).
I got the MUFE eye pencil set for some stupid over inflated price from eBay. This is what happens when you insult your American penpal. You have to resort to buying US stuff via eBay – sigh.
Here they are. The pencils are TIDGY! And they are super irritating to open because the lids are stuck on tight and I nearly snapped 2 of them trying to pull the lid off. The shade selection is nice although I would have liked a green there.
MUFE is a lovely brand. It’s like the grown up sister of MAC, MAC being the whorey sister who does anything she can for attention.
These pencils are lovley and creamy, and so far, it seems to come off fine on my waterline. They are supposed to be waterproof and if you give it a little while to set, it does indeed, stay put.
So far so good! You US ladies can get a bargain since its on sale at Sephora.